The London Mayoral election is at serious risk of being stolen
By Harry Phibbs
Last updated at 12:13 PM on 2nd March 2012
Picture the scene on the evening of Friday 4 May this year.
Ken Livingstone has just been re-elected to his old job of Mayor of London by the narrowest of margins. Congratulatory telegrams come in from Hugo Chavez and Fidel Castro. Lee Jasper is announced among the new appointments to City Hall.
Boris Johnson refuses to say if he will seek a return to the House of Commons at a future by-election. The pollsters have been confounded as they had shown a narrow win for Boris.
The evidence of voter fraud allegedly taking place in Tower Hamlets, risks the London Mayoral election between Ken Livingstone, left, and Boris Johnson, right, says Harry Phibbs
More from Harry Phibbs...
- Scrap the tax: British business finally begins to fight back 01/03/12
- Why the Labour Party should be backing workfare scheme 27/02/12
- Liam Fox is right. The Government must cut spending more to allow tax cuts 22/02/12
- If anti smoking plain package zealots succeed, the only winner will be the black market 20/02/12
- Who will campaign for capitalism? 02/02/12
- Children's literature should uphold traditional values but has become a popularity contest 23/12/11
- Nothing has changed about our relationship with Europe, yet... 12/12/11
- Now they've shot Fox, the Tory Right has no leader 17/10/11
- VIEW FULL ARCHIVE
Then it emerges that Livingstone's narrow victory was entirely due to one borough. That of Tower Hamlets where there have been remarkably sharp increases in turnout, the number of voters on the register and share of the vote received by Livingstone.
The evidence of massive voter fraud taking place in Tower Hamlets is overwhelming. 'Postal vote farming' where extra names are registered at an address, is not an isolated or random occurrence but is taking place systematically.
The Evening Standard has investigated and found that 'dozens of flats are holding up to eight people per bedroom, according to the electoral register.'
In one case 12 adults are still listed as voters at a three-bedroom flat in Mile End despite having moved out about four months before officials gathered data for the register. A lettings agent said that only 'three or four' of those named had ever lived there.
Cllr Peter Golds, the Conservative opposition leader of the council, has written on Conservative Home this morning about the failure for anyone to take action.
'In 2009 I handed over to the police copies of emails regarding postal vote farming,' he writes. 'The police spoke to the sender who "promised not to do it again" and therefore indicated a prosecution would not be in "the public interest", despite the fine for this being £5,000.
'The electoral commission advises that concerned citizens approach the town hall, who then ask you to send your evidence to the police, who go back to the electoral commission on this merry go round of inertia.'
Cllr Golds adds there is similar indifference to 'appalling intimidation at polling stations.'
Evidence: In one case 12 adults are still listed as voters at a three-bedroom flat in Mile End despite having moved out before officials gathered register data
This is not a new problem. The 2008 mayoral election saw the Labour share of the vote sharply increase in Tower Hamlets against the trend elsewhere. In the 2004 results Livingstone beat the then Conservative candidate Steve Norris by 16,229 to 10,157.
In the 2008 results we saw Livingstone beat Boris Johnson in that borough by 37,361 to 17,509.
Then we had in April 2010, just before the General Election, an increase in the electorate of 7,000 recorded in just one month.
This is a council where later that year the directly elected Mayor, Lutfur Rahman, stood as an independent but with the support of Livingstone against the official Labour candidate.
Reassurance: Tory MP Gary Streeter, said the Electoral Commission had been assured by the police and Tower Hamlets that the issue was being treated seriously
Tower Hamlets Council's response is to deny that there is a problem and of course there is no suggestion any of the participants in recent elections were party to any fraud.
'No cases of electoral fraud have been found in Tower Hamlets,' A council spokesman said, adding that the borough 'suffers from very high levels of overcrowding.'
So if the council can't or won't act, who will? What is the Electoral Commission doing about this? Nothing. It has a budget of £24million but when I rang them it became all too clear that it has no power to ensure free and fair elections take place - merely to offer 'guidance.'
It could act as a whistle blower but won't even do that.
When the Conservative MP Lee Scott raised the matter in Parliament he was told by his colleague Gary Streeter MP, who speaks on their behalf of the Electoral Commission, that 'the Commission has been assured by the police and Tower Hamlets electoral registration officer (ERO) that the issue is being treated with the appropriate seriousness.'
Streeter added: 'The Electoral Commission informs me that it has made no specific assessment of the level of (a) over registration or (b) fraudulent registration in the London borough of Tower Hamlets.'
Still all the boxes are ticked: 'The Commission monitors the performance of electoral registration officers (EROs) in Great Britain, including their plans for preventing and detecting electoral malpractice. The most recent report of performance against the standards set by the Commission found that the ERO for Tower Hamlets exceeded this standard in 2010.'
The Cabinet Office Minister Mark Harper, also proposes to do nothing - while 'taking the matter very seriously', of course.
So there we are. There is a serious risk of the election for Mayor of London being stolen yet nothing is being done to avert this from happening in the mother of democracy.
Perhaps we need some international observers from developing countries to help us out. We seem to be unable to manage to ensure a democratic election takes place.
- A parasite ate my face: How traveller who proposed to his...
- Apocalypse now: Russian artist transforms real-life...
- Britain's richest woman takes delivery of £100m superyacht -...
- Talk about flex appeal! Incredible pictures capture every...
- Benefits cheat mother invented SIX children (and pretended...
- Cork blimey! Businessman splashes out £125,000 on ONE bottle...
- 'Driving and facebooking is not safe! Haha': Chilling last...
- Gordon Ramsay forced to pay £41,700 for no show at...
- Sex gang passed young girls around THOUSANDS of men, claims...
- Womanising Nigerian fraudster hijacked identities of...
- Married father who 'accidentally' downloaded child porn...
- 'The mountain is collapsing, we're going to die!' Terrifying...
NEWS YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT
- Mother of four 'made MILLIONS from Manhattan brothel for politicians, bankers and celebrities' Busted after five-year investigation
- 'The world has abandoned us' At least 60 Syrians killed trying to flee Homs as troops target bridges used for escape
- Benefits cheat mother invented SIX children (and pretended she and her two REAL kids were disabled to pocket £42,000)
- 'How to wash trousers? Give it to your woman, it's her job!' Twitter outrage over 'sexist' washing label
- Bin Laden WAS NOT buried at sea, but sent to the U.S. for cremation Leaked emails doubt the official White House story
- Tycoon's four daughters sue over £1million inheritance tax They claim solicitors failed to protect them from death duties
- Eurostar passengers stranded for up to nine hours as cable fault causes chaos Four trains on the London to Paris rail line were axed yesterday
- Womanising Nigerian fraudster hijacked identities of soldiers and nurses to open 725 bank accounts in £1.3m benefits swindle
- Council tenants to get PAID £500 a year to do their own DIY If tenants carry out basic repairs like decorating, and fixing leaky taps
- The £1.40 heart pill lifesaver 10,000 patients a year could be saved by newly-licensed drug
- Welcome to Barbados, your bags are flying back to the UK Passengers left without luggage after ground crew couldn't get hold door open
- A parasite ate my face How traveller who proposed to his girlfriend in Peru was almost killed by flesh-eating grub
- Wife speaks of 'heartbreak' after U.S. judge remands British businessman in custody Elaine Tappin said it was an 'outrage'
- Apocalypse now Russian artist transforms real-life photographs to show how cities might look after the end of the world
- Find the white widow Fingerprints confirm terror suspect IS British mother say Kenyan detectives
- 'I felt repulsed and dirty and wanted to kill myself' Schoolgirl victims of teenage girl who dressed as boy to date them speak of their anguish
- Evil pair jailed for total of 55 years for torturing 15-year-old boy to death after accusing him of being a witch
- 'You'll never see your grandchildren' What £45m EuroMillions winner told estranged mother after she tried to heal seven-year rift following his jackpot
- Huge asteroid to hurtle past Earth next year - so close it will fly UNDER many man-made satellites
- No wonder we laugh at them! From Ed Miliband and Wallace to Mayor Boris and Barney Rubble... the politicians and their cartoon alter egos
- Tesco manager conned £60,000 out of staff for son’s ‘fatal illness’ ...and spent the money on holidays to Hawaii and Las Vegas
- Duchess of Cambridge to give first speech as a Royal Patron Kate will address families at The Treehouse children's hospices charity
- Homeowners to pay £735 a year MORE after Halifax hikes mortgage rates Has sparked threat of customer exodus
- Fake barrister who donned a wig and robe to represent a friend is found out Given away by 'hopelessly wrong' legal statements
- 'She's nothing less than miraculous' Father speaks of his pride at IVF baby daughter who took 21 years to arrive
- Cork blimey! Businessman splashes out £125,000 on ONE bottle of champagne as he spends £200,000 in a single bar round
- Osborne 'backs down' on controversial bid to cut child benefit following Tory revolt Paving the way for a major climbdown
- Is this the meteorite that terrified Britain? Florist claims she found space rock in school field while walking her dog
- We really are a perfect match! Wife set to save husband's life after doctors discover she is million-to-one matching organ
- Britain's richest woman takes delivery of £100m superyacht - the largest ever built here (and it comes with its own fold-down beach club)
EDITOR'S BEST OF THE WEB
- Married father who 'accidentally' downloaded child porn instead of music is banned from being alone with his eight-year-old daughter
- Bin Laden WAS NOT buried at sea, but sent to the U.S. for cremation, leaked emails reveal
- Benefits cheat mother invented SIX children (and pretended she and her two REAL kids were disabled to pocket £42,000)
- Tycoon's four daughters sue over £1million inheritance tax: They claim solicitors failed to protect them from death duties
- Council tenants to get PAID £500 a year to do their own DIY
- Music teacher forced to resign from £10,000-a-year private school after head put her on ‘hit list’ because he didn’t like her ‘facial expressions’
- Doctors fear for 5ft 3in tall 'human doughtnut' who is 6ft 6in round his WAIST
- Did the MOON sink the Titanic? Freak tides caused icebergs to fill shipping lanes 100 years ago
- Welcome to Barbados, your bags are flying back to the UK: Passengers left without luggage after ground crew couldn't get hold door open
- Models vent their anger on Twitter as Eurostar cable fault disrupts Paris Fashion Week and leaves passengers stranded for up to nine hours
- Gordon Ramsay forced to pay £41,700 for no show at transplant fundraiser... because his mother had a heart attack
- A parasite ate my face: How traveller who proposed to his girlfriend in Peru was almost killed by flesh-eating grub
- Apocalypse now: Russian artist transforms real-life photographs to show how cities might look after the end of the world
- Criminal killed in police ambush was not armed when he was shot dead, reveals watchdog
- 'I begged him not to do anything stupid': Twin brother of blinded PC David Rathband reveals plea days before suicide
- 'We're hooked on foreign workers': Immigration minister tells businesses
- Get rich AND die trying: Ambitious people earn more money - but they die younger and are no happier, says study
- Cricket star launching first Twitter libel claim tells court he was hit for six by Tweet that said he was 'a match fixer'
- 'Driving and facebooking is not safe! Haha': Chilling last text sent by teenage driver seconds before she died in 80mph horror crash
- Fat lot of good: How eating more cheese and milk could make you brainier
- Caught on camera: The shocking moment that got rugby player JAILED after hitting opponent so hard he broke his jaw
- MORE HEADLINES
these are not our people!
- simon, UK, 04/3/2012 14:28
Report abuse